At the start of the twentieth century, a young girl and her family emigrate from Lithuania in search of a better life in America, only to land on the Emerald Isle instead. In 1958, a mute Jewish boy locked away in a mental institution outside of Dublin forms an unlikely friendship with a man consumed by the story of the love he lost nearly two decades earlier. And in present-day London, an Irish journalist is forced to confront her conflicting notions of identity and family when her Jewish boyfriend asks her to make a true leap of faith. These three arcs, which span generations and intertwine in revelatory ways, come together to tell the haunting story of Ireland’s all-but-forgotten Jewish community. Ruth Gilligan’s beautiful and heartbreaking Nine Folds Make a Paper Swan explores the question of just how far we will go to understand who we really are, and to feel at home in the world.
My thoughts:
There are 3 POVs in this book. Ruth's family was on their way to America, escaping Lithuania, but ended up in Ireland. She grows up there, makes a life there. I would have wished more of her story, Ireland changing and all that, instead it moved pretty past and we got tidbits here and there.
The second POV was my least fav, a boy in a mental institution, he has stopped talking and well, he just there.
The third POV was my favorite. Ashling loves her boyfriend but he wants to marry a Jewish girl, and she is wondering if she should convert.
But honestly, I wish the book had been longer, or one narrator could have been skipped so the other stories could have gotten more time. I wanted more flesh on the bones. I wanted to get to know them more. It made it confusing at time too when a new chapter started, but whose was it? Someone just started talking. It could have done with some header or something.
Why am I thinking of Joyce now...it was not like that, but they all did think a lot. We did not really see things around them. Things that were happening, it really was a character novel instead and we were in their heads.
Conclusion:
Jewish lives in Ireland. Different generations and interwoven stories.
There are 3 POVs in this book. Ruth's family was on their way to America, escaping Lithuania, but ended up in Ireland. She grows up there, makes a life there. I would have wished more of her story, Ireland changing and all that, instead it moved pretty past and we got tidbits here and there.
The second POV was my least fav, a boy in a mental institution, he has stopped talking and well, he just there.
The third POV was my favorite. Ashling loves her boyfriend but he wants to marry a Jewish girl, and she is wondering if she should convert.
But honestly, I wish the book had been longer, or one narrator could have been skipped so the other stories could have gotten more time. I wanted more flesh on the bones. I wanted to get to know them more. It made it confusing at time too when a new chapter started, but whose was it? Someone just started talking. It could have done with some header or something.
Why am I thinking of Joyce now...it was not like that, but they all did think a lot. We did not really see things around them. Things that were happening, it really was a character novel instead and we were in their heads.
Conclusion:
Jewish lives in Ireland. Different generations and interwoven stories.
Paperback, 336 pages
Expected publication: April 6th 2017 by Atlantic Books
Historical fiction / Fiction
For review
I do like immigration stories so would consider this book.
ReplyDeleteNice
DeleteDefinitely something new to me. Jewish lives in Ireland? That's a rarity on my shelves.
ReplyDeleteThey were a few
DeleteThis is unlike what I've read. Sounds interesting for sure.
ReplyDelete:=D
DeleteI think I've heard this kinda story. Is it a movie? I don't know. This kinda of story is very different than the ones I'm used to read, but I'm curious. I'll add this on my list just in case I need something different.
ReplyDeleteAnyway, awesome review! :)
I can't say it rings a bell for me, considering the 3 stories and all
DeleteThat's a good bit going in one book. Weird on pov 2.
ReplyDeleteTotally
DeleteLove the title, tho.
ReplyDeleteI can not make anything paper, not even a snowflake
DeleteIn multiple POV I'm like you, I wind up with a favorite and hoping for more told in their POV
ReplyDeleteThere is always a favorite :)
DeleteSounds like it could have gone deeper with a character or two. Thanks for sharing. :)
ReplyDeleteLonger and deeper
DeleteSounds interesting, but it does sound like it needed more action.
ReplyDeleteWell..some bad things do happen
DeleteNot my kind of story, but I love the title of the book!
ReplyDelete:)
DeleteHmm sounds good so a pity some aspects weren't developed more. Very promising.
ReplyDeletemayben too bad about the POV you didn't really like
ReplyDeleteIt happens
DeleteSounds interesting - hadn't heard of it before.
ReplyDeleteIf done well, the multi POV and time span plot-line can be so much fun. I hadn't heard of this book, I may have to find it at my library. :)
ReplyDeleteTake a look :D
DeleteDespite the weird POV, I think I would enjoy this.
ReplyDeleteI get that
ReplyDeleteOn one hand, it is great that the author had characters you liked so much you wanted more. On the other hand, you were left wanting and that isn't a good thing when you're at the end of a book. Sounds like it was still enjoyable.
ReplyDeleteMelanie @ Hot Listens & Rabid Reads
True. I wanted more, but it was not enough, tough one
Delete