Saturday, 10 November 2012

Lady Scoundrel Saturday: Lord of Scoundrels - Loretta Chase


Lady Scoundrel Saturdays
Scorn, Sensitivity and Sense!
Part 2 of The Lady Scoundrels reviews Lord of Scoundrels by Loretta Chase. Today Rameau aka Sense is bringing you her views of the book.


When I finished reading this book and went on Goodreads to see what others had thought of it, I was surprised. The four star ratings didn't surprise me, the five star ratings did. As good as I felt after closing the book (or activating the screensaver on my Kindle) I didn't think I'd just finished reading a five star book. I didn't think I'd finished reading anything as close to such (im)perfection I expect from a five star book. I did think I finished reading an entertaining, character driven romance about two very irritating people who were a match made in heaven or hell depending on your belief system.

Lord Dain—don't ask me to look and type out his full name, I beg of you—was the titular character in the book, a true Lord of Scoundrels.He's not welcomed into polite society despite his breeding and he doesn't aspire to spend his evenings with the genteel folk of the French capitol, he'd much rather spend his time in more pleasurable endeavours with the less than reputable Parisians. He has the money to do it, but the people he drags down with him don't. That is how he trips to the greatest obstacle life has thrown at him yet, Lady Jessica Trent.

Despite being virginal, Jessica isn't one of the vapid insipid ingénues that plague the world of historical romance. She's determined to save her brother from ruin and she has the character to pull it off. Jessica is capable, shrewd, brazen to a point, and most of all self-assured. She doesn't wait to be chased and wooed, she goes after what she wants. And she knows boys of all ages as the author points out, repeatedly. She's also smart, but she isn't all-knowing, but she faces head on all the challenges presented to her, including her husband.

That's another part I liked about this book, that the romance didn't end at the altar, but that it continued well into the marriage

After two novels, I finally figured out why I like Loretta Chase's books as much as I do despite their obvious downfalls and dated modern attitudes shining through the writing. It's because she creates complex and interesting characters and I have a soft spot for character driven stories. There are only so many ways to create interesting characters that fit into the strict society of old without turning them into boring cardboard cutouts most authors churn out.

Despite his rakish habits, it's Dain who is the insecure ingénue. He's deluded about his looks as unfashionable as they are and he's deluded about his own worth and influence on others. He believes in the only power that hasn't failed him in his life—money—but inside he's a wounded puppy and an unloved child looking for someone to hold him while he cries.

“In any case, to hesitate in such a situation was to indicate doubt, or worse, weakness. To do so with a man was dangerous. To do so with a woman was fatal.”

The only problem I have with this beautiful characterisation is that if you're the sort of person to skip prologues, you'll never find a shred of sympathy for the man. The way he behaves may be understandable, but in so many ways it is also unforgivable. A better writer could have worked that horrible history within the main body of text without having to glue on an apologetic introduction to the horrors of growing up to be Lord Dain.

At the same time Jessica is the bold seducer who works within the society and makes the society work for her. She not only overcomes the period appropriate hindrances for her sex, but uses them in her favour. <spoiler>Yes, I'm talking about the shooting</spoiler>.

As much as I loved incongruence between reality and his perception of himself, I think I would have loved the story more had Dain truly been hideous and had Jessica been less of a Beauty to her beast.

Although, I liked Lord of Scoundrels better than I did Captives of the Night. I do think the latter had a better if under utilised story of the two. In essence Lord of Scoundrels is a straightforward story about two people meeting and working through a random series of obstacles before settling to live the rest of their lives together as a <spoiler>blended</spoiler> family.

4 stars

Series:                                            Scoundrels #3
Pages:                                             375 (paperback)
Published:                                       Originally 1995
Source:                                           Anachronist


(Next week I am up, eeek)

20 comments:

  1. In general I agree with you. Chase can create interesting characters and they move the story forward, making you keep reading even if the story is basically always the same. I personally gave Lord of Scoundres three stars on GR and it ranked lower than Captives.

    That's another part I liked about this book, that the romance didn't end at the altar, but that it continued well into the marriage

    Hear hear, that's also a feature I appreciate in my romantic novels because it is a real challenge. It's easy to describe a romance at the very beginning or in the middle, when you still see the world through pink lenses. It is far more difficult to render the stablized, civilized relationship in a marriage, when everything seems to be taken for granted and there are no sparks around.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I saw that, and I can understand why you did. For me, Captives of the Night was the boring one whereas Lord of Scoundrels kept me entertained. I didn't even stop to think about the obvious flaws in the plot and story structure until after I finished reading the book.

      This book reminded me of that one Milan book I've yet to read... The one with the married couple reconnecting.

      Delete
    2. This book reminded me of that one Milan book I've yet to read... The one with the married couple reconnecting.

      Knock me with a feather...I suppose I haven't read it either!

      Delete
  2. Great review as always Rameau :)
    I am now shaking in my pants, how on earth will I write a good review? But that is why I am sensitivity and silly too ;D

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. YAY, Blodeuedd's review will be next!!!
      BTW don't let me start complaining about the cover art.

      Delete
    2. I can do that ;D I love to complain about cover art

      Delete
    3. It was my pleasure. And you need to stop worrying, just read the book and enjoy... or rant. Let the spirits move you ;)

      Delete
    4. Hm rant..I do love to rant, it makes me feel free

      Delete
  3. it sounds like a nice book but I don't know if it's really for me. I'm glad you enjoyed this one better than the other book you read.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks. I used to love romances like these in the 90's. Now, however, times have changed and so have I. It makes recommending the thing a challenge.

      Delete
  4. 4 stars is still a great rating coming from you! Sounds like one I would enjoy!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. 4 stars is a very good rating from me. It lured me into its magic.

      Delete
  5. You had me at "looking for someone to hold him while he cries." *sigh*

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Are you a fan of damaged heroes then? I must warn you that the prologue is heavy on the heartache of a rough childhood front. I wish you all the luck with this book.

      Delete
  6. I am all about the characters, so sounds like a winner.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Wow a 4 star rating. I can't remember what I thought of the book. I haven't reviewed it on my blog. Still, I know I did not love it very much, but it is my best friends favourite book.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I can definitely understand why you wouldn't like it, but I can also understand why people would. Maybe I was just in a good mood when rating this.

      Delete
  8. Good review hun!

    I love this idea. ^.^

    ReplyDelete

Thank you for your lovely comment. I appreciate and love them all :D

I answer them all here.

Contributors

Copyright © 2008-2014 Book Girl of Mur-y-Castell All Rights Reserved. Proudly powered by Blogger

  © Blogger template Starry by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008 Modified by Lea

Back to TOP