Saturday 8 October 2011

Review: Proof by Seduction by Courtney Milan

Series: Carhart #1
Genre: Historical romance
Pages: 352, ebook
Published: 2009
Publisher: HQN
Review by Anachronist

Gareth Carhard, the Marquess of Blakely et cetera, a gifted scientist, an aristocrat and a sworn, stone-cold bachelor, has just returned from Brazil to take care of the estate and the title left to him by his grandfather. He is bored in London but he must perform his duties. For example he  must save his younger cousin, Ned, from the clutches of a skillful and fraudulent fortune-teller. Ned takes him to Madame Esmerelda (a.k.a Jenny Keeble) asap– poor boy thinks that woman is a true psychic, never realizing she’s been bilking him for almost two years. In his view Madame saved him from a suicide during a bout of teenage depression and she has always acted like the combination of an indulgent, although a bit spooky parent and a best friend to him. Gareth doesn’t understand it at all. He yearns for revealing the truth behind the obviously false persona of Madame Esmerelda. That’s how he involves himself with a woman who, coming from a humble background, managed to find an original and relatively profitable if not shady career in England during the 1830s. A dangerously intelligent woman. A pretty woman. In short an unusually interesting woman for a Marquess and a single man. Gareth’s unexpected attraction to Jenny defies his notion of logic. Will their relationship bring them more joys or more bitterness ? Who will win and who will profit from it?

What I liked:

It’s the second historical romance by this author which I read and actually Ms. Milan’s debut novel. I was slightly shocked it was so good. Once again it’s a bit different than the normal romantic fare. First of all I would like to mention psychologically complex and engaging set of characters. Ned, Gareth and Jenny are very close to fully-fledged people, well-rounded and believable from the psychological point of view. Their actions are always logical and justified by their particular psychological profile. I especially liked the descriptions of Gareth’s poor attempts at communication with the outside world– the guy is one of these painfully shy introverts who never know what is expected from them and what to say so they have learned to cover any shortcomings by haughtiness and disdain. It was described very well and, being a kind of introvert myself, I could relate to him.

Jenny is the linchpin of the novel – a person who makes things happen even though she doesn’t always mean it. I liked the fact that her romance made her see her shady profession in a different light. She also had the courage to ditch it. The awakening in both Jenny and Gareth was a poignant moment – definitely more serious than topics usually mentioned in pink romances. I don’t doubt that nowadays Jenny would have a great career as a psychologist as she was intelligent enough to learn pretty quickly what her clients expected from her and she understood why they visited her at all – not for predictions but for support. What’s more, she educated herself in different areas in order to sound plausible and she was pretty successful at it. I also liked the fact that she learned to value her own person and she really knew what she wanted to achieve before anybody suggested that to her.

Once again the book features a plot who didn’t disappoint me and the sense of humour which was able to disarm me successfully – Ned, a gawky, sweet young man, and his cold but socially inept cousin providing much needed comic relief time and again (Ned’s exchange of invectives with Lord Ware, the father of his prospective bride, was simply priceless). In general I found Ned a great addition to the leading pair - his actions pushed the narration forward, not letting us get bored by the obvious passion between Jenny and Gareth (no, they didn’t wait till the marriage because, firstly, marriage was never their plan and secondly, Jenny was already a kind of a fallen woman so why bother?).

What I didn’t like:

Of course I didn’t like the fact that, in the end, somebody like Lord Blakely married somebody like Jenny Keeble/Madame Esmerelda. How could I like it? It was totally improbable, downright scandalous etc. etc. but who will listen to my arguments? Cinderella rules…In other words, the books sticks to the classic pink formula – as soon as Gareth realizes he can't live without Jenny he jumps through a few last hoops and she agrees to marry him. No, I don’t think it is a spoiler as I saw the ending from a mile away, but I admit it was kind of sweet. However, I had to brush my teeth afterwards just in case there was too much sugar in it. Cavities are no laughing matter.

Jenny is a heroine who pulled herself by her own bootstraps against all odds although she was sent to school at a tender age of four (way too young), never knowing her parents, and was never cared after in an appropriate way. Once again I might just say it was highly unbelievable that she became such an intelligent, sensitive woman but who will pay attention? Repetitive, aren’t I? Speaking about repetitiveness…I also notices some of it in the book (comparing ‘Proof by Seduction’ to the first Milan book which I read and reviewed not so long ago – ‘Unclaimed’) but I suppose there is a limited number of variations how e.g. a love-making scene can be written so perhaps it is not so big a flaw…still when two very different characters repeat verbatim the same phrases in roughly the same circumstances it makes you think ‘huh?’.

Overall I must say that explicitly-described sex scenes, a traditional feature in romance novels as far as I know, are more often than not a complete passion-killer for me. The ones in this novel weren’t very bad but still... sometimes really less is more. 

My final remark: if you are looking for setting that can immerse you into the period of 1830s England or, more precisely, London, you would probably be left a bit disappointed – but, after all, this is more about the characters and their interactions within the given setting. And the romance, of course. 

Final verdict:

If you are looking for a light read with a well-balanced amount of humour, sensuality and strength throughout the story and with a great set of lifelike characters, Milan’s novels can give you that much. Don’t be too inquisitive or too choosy though, just immerse in the narration and enjoy your HEA. If you find it a tad too syrupy sweet, brush your teeth. 

I know I know, no flash yet!
Thanks Ana for this one :D I so wanna read more by Milan so I am happy to feature her on my blog until then


  1. Sounds cute, but I do agree. I always think that (in reality these characters would never be together). It just doesn't happen. Maybe if she came across the town's butcher...well maybe things would be different. Great review.

  2. Thanks for your comments!

    Carrie, it wasn't bad!

    @Carole - my thoughts exactly!

    @kimba88 -thanks again!

  3. I really, really hope one day you will fall head over heals with a romance novel Anachronist! Until then, your reviews will make me laugh a lot.

  4. Being a romance novelist would test the limits of my creativity; as you said, there's only some many ways you can write a love scene.

  5. No freaking way!!!

    *stunned in the headlights*

    How are you reading all these ROMANCES??? I love this review based on that. :)

  6. Thank you Ana. And I am just as stunned as Melissa seeing you reading all these romances..well two, but that is way on the way to reading one a day ;)

  7. That is quite the cover!
    I enjoyed this review. I don't like syrupy sweet HEA's though.

  8. @Aurian - I think it is possible but it would have to be a very special romance novel, intelligent, witty and plausible.

    @Stephanie - you are completely right; it is especially difficult in the case of romance series.

    @Melissa - I love surprising you my dear, this is one of things that keep me reading even when a book becomes too fluffy ;D

    @Blodeuedd - thank you for having me again so soon! Nay, it is one of the ways of quitting them completely. Try them and see that they are not so good. Ms Milan is kind of exception to the rule. I still abhor Harlequins.

    @naida - the cover is...well...revealing. ;) Syrupy HEAs are the bane of romances.

  9. That is quite the cover. I agree on sex scenes - less is more. It's fun to use your own imagination to some extent too. Glad you enjoyed this one.

  10. This sounds like a great weekend/vacation read! I'll have to check this one out!

  11. Darlene, thank you, I did enjoy this one!

    Amused - it works even better when read during those long dark autumn evenings ;)

  12. Melissa
    I know right, I am in total shock too ;)

  13. Ha! Love that review :-) I've had a few "brush your teeth" books. I'm not a huge fan of historical romances but I keep trying and I have found a few good ones thanks to Carrie from In the Hammock Blog.
    I've never read anything by Courtney Milan before but I always see her name popping up everywhere.

  14. Sometimes books like these are just what the doctor ordered!!!

  15. Shocking you, Blodeuedd and Melissa, is one of my greater digital pleasures!
    *evil grin*

    Karen, there are exceptions in every genre. That's why reviews and book blogs are for - to help you find them.

    Staci - only when the doctor is kind of intelligent but yes; such books are sometimes better than antibiotics ;)

  16. Fantastic review. I like how you clearly state your likes and dislikes of the books and then your overall impression. This one does sound like a nice light read that you don't have to do a lot of thinking with. I'm going to put it on my To Check Out Later list. :-D

  17. I'm not sure what to think right This is one of the books I had chosen to read to help me get into Historicals in November... *sigh* I am suddenly questioning whether or not I am the type of reader who won't delve too much into things and ask too many questions. LOL



Copyright © 2008-2020 Book Girl of Mur-y-Castell All Rights Reserved. Proudly powered by Blogger

  © Blogger template Starry by 2008 Modified by Lea

Back to TOP